Everyone knows it's hard for me to pass on a request, so zdaughter and I sat down (at Whitney's request) to rank all eight Mission: Impossible movies. It went like this.
zman: My friend Whitney asked us to do something.
zdaughter: Cool, what does she want?
zman: Whitney is a man.
zdaughter: Oh Whitney, right, he has a bad tattoo doesn't he?
zman: Several of my friends do but yes, he does. He asked us to rank all eight Mission: Impossibles.
zdaughter: Yes! I'll get a pencil and paper!
You may recall that she thinks of herself as a Mandalorian but she's also very much Hermione Granger--she's the kid who always raises her hand for every question just to keep the class moving along because she's paying exceedingly close attention and gets bored when things bog down. She only got one question wrong on a math test so far this year and she's still pissed about it. This is all her mother. Outside of class she doesn't take herself too seriously. She gets this from me. Here's her spring school photo, for example.
I'm telling you all this to help frame up her approach to the M:I ranking. She loves cold blooded killers, strong female characters, fast pacing, perfectionism, and a dollop of silliness. And she's a zperson so she has no time for schmaltz, cheese, or maudlinism.
With that, here are her rankings:
8. Mission: Impossible 2 - Remarkably, an action movie directed by John Woo with Thandie Newton as the leading lady and Dougray Scott as the main villain is a dud. zdaughter's take: "This is so cheesy. He has long hair and he's always tossing it around. The fight scenes are ridiculous, he's always flipping and spinning for no reason. It's like he's trying to fight like a Jedi but he doesn't have a lightsaber." I agree with all of this, I'm amazed that the franchise survived this cornball schlock.
7. Mission: Impossible 3 - Remarkably, an action movie directed by J.J. Abrams with Michelle Monaghan as the leading lady and Philip Seymour Hoffman as the main villain is a dud. I sense a trend. zdaughter's take: "This one's corny too. His hair is short but now he's retired? There's no way Ethan Hunt would retire. And of course he has to come out of retirement to save his girlfriend. I wasn't worried when he died, I knew they would bring him back to life. Tom Cruise isn't going to die." I agree with all of this too. Blowing up a Lamborghini added insult to injury.
6. Mission: Impossible - The Final Reckoning - This is the eighth episode, currently in theaters near you. zdaughter's take: "It's a good movie but it's too long and it's stressful. It's a long time to be that stressed out. Gabriel wasn't a great bad guy and it's hard to understand how the Entity works. But there is lots of action and Grace is cool. I wish they didn't kill [redacted]." Grace is a thief, fyi, and zdaughter's favorite character in the franchise. They could've lopped 45 minutes off this beast and told the exact same story. At one point Cruise narrowly survives a crazy situation that drags on for half an hour and then he explains all the other stuff they need to do to accomplish the mission and I looked at my watch and exclaimed "Jesus Christ, we've been here for 90 minutes and they have more to do?!" It's just too long.
5. Mission: Impossible - Rogue Nation - This is the fifth episode and the first one directed by Christopher McQuarrie, who directed all the subsequent episodes. I'm surprised she has it this low but her top four are her top four and she isn't budging for anyone. zdaughter's take: "It's a good movie but it isn't as good as the ones I like better. I don't like the color filter." I have to agree on the color issue. I don't know if we had a streaming problem on Prime but the colors were way over-saturated and muddy. But it introduces Ilsa Faust, a world-class assassin and zdaughter's second favorite character in the franchise.
4. Mission: Impossible - Fallout - This is the sixth episode and it's also surprisingly low but this is zdaughter's list and I'm not messing with it. "This one is good. It has Walker [Henry Cavill] and the White Widow [Vanessa Kirby] and Ethan Hunt is John Lark." That all makes sense if you've seen the movie. It's a banger--this would've been in my top two if I wrote the list.
3. Mission: Impossible - This is the one that started it all. zdaughter's take: "This is the one where he drops down from the ceiling and he can't touch the floor and the rope slips and he stops an inch away from the floor. And he jumps off a helicopter just as it explodes and it throws him onto a train." In other words it has iconic scenes that everyone remembers. It's the OG, the Sean Connery of the franchise. Number three is where I would place it too.
2. Mission: Impossible - Ghost Protocol - This is the fourth episode, where the franchise turns away from the soft dreck of episodes 2 and 3 into hard espionage stories. Sort of how the James Bond franchise did a complete tonal change when they moved from Pierce Brosnan's "Die Another Day" to Daniel Craig's "Casino Royale." zdaughter's take: "Ethan Hunt climbs on the outside of a building like a budget Spider-Man, there's a crazy chase scene in a sandstorm, the Kremlin explodes, Hawkeye is in it too." The Avengers crossover likely boosted this one in her eyes but I agree that it's a ton of fun. It would've been in the top two on my list.
1. Mission: Impossible - Dead Reckoning - This is the seventh episode and a bit of a surprise for the top spot. But it makes sense when you hear zdaughter's take: "It has Agent Carter [Grace is played by Hayley Atwell, who played Agent Carter which I encourage you to watch on Disney+, zdaughter highly endorses it too] but it's weird to see her not in the 1940s. It also has Ilsa and Paris [Paris is a female killing machine]. The best part is when Agent Carter tries to drive the Fiat but can only go in circles and Paris is just sitting there like what the hell. It's the funniest of all of them." This is all true, this is the episode that takes itself the least seriously, that occasionally puts tongue in cheek and humanizes the characters. For example, there's a scene where Tom Cruise kills a bunch of people (this happens often) and Hayley Atwell (who met him a few hours ago) is comically shocked speechless and Cruise has to convince her that it's all ok. In another scene, Atwell and Cruise are handcuffed together and hilarity ensues. Cruise later ends up staggering around Rome, handcuffed to a steering wheel. It's the only movie where Ethan Hunt gets goofed on and it has three badass female characters who help save the world, so that's why it's zdaughter's #1.