This week four highly respected players of the U.S. Women’s
National Team and Hope Solo filed a wage discrimination lawsuit against U.S. Soccer,
the governing body in ‘M(m?)erica. The women argue that while representing the country
on the pitch they earn roughly 40% of what the men garner despite the fact they
are vastly more successful. U.S. Soccer argues that the men generate more
revenue though attendance and TV rights and testicular acreage (Ed Note: U.S. Soccer may argue this, but they've got a bigger issue here. The governing body's own data suggests that the distaff Nats will actually generate more profit over the next two years than their counterparts with external genitalia). Two plausibly reasonable
arguments that might result in a bit of a shitstorm given the way the payscales
of the two teams are vastly different.
In addition to qualifiers, both teams are obligated to play
20 exhibition “friendlies” per year for which the women are paid a base of
$72,000 and a $1,350 bonus if they win. The men are guaranteed $5,000 and
bonuses up to $8,000 for a win depending on the rank of their opponents. If the
men beat Spain or Germany they make $18,156 while the women would make $4,950
for a similar victory. In other words, if the women win all 20 international
friendlies they take home $99,000, if the men lose all 20 they take home
$100,000. The women argue similar disparities in pay for competition play and
even note a per diem discrepancy for national
($50 women/$62.50 men) and international duties ($60w/75m).
U.S. Soccer contends that the women collectively bargained
for and approved this payout scale. The suit stems from the fact that this
agreement expired in 2012 and U.S. Soccer contends a 2013 MOU extended it to
which the union disagrees. I’m not a lawyer although I play one on two of my
resumes and this case raises a number of financial, social and ethical
questions. A few that come to mind:
Why would U.S. Soccer structure such disparate payscales for
each team?
Is it true that the per diem discrepancy is because the men
need to eat more food?
Do the U.S. Paralympic soccer teams have even lower per
diems since they ostensibly require even less nutrition than the USMNT and
USWNT?
Who are Rory and Joey Feek and why is my news feed
continually spammed since one of them died?
Given that soccer is the only major sport in the U.S. where
the men and women’s team each has a dedicated fan base (USWNT averages 12K
attendees per game versus men’s 28K) does U.S. Soccer have any obligation to
structure pay equality based on performance? Women’s soccer is relatively new
with fewer teams, since it’s inception in 1991 the U.S. women have won three World
Cups. The men are average at best and never will win the big Cup (Ed Note: Never is a long time. We made the quarters as recently as X years ago. I bet we win one in the lifetime of at least one of us.). As a biased fan of the
women’s team I say, “give ‘em hell girls!” But seriously, some of the top
sports headlines of 2015 included the USWNT, Serena Williams and Ronda Rousey. Equal
pay for equal work and play might make us look a tad less troglodytic to future
generations.
In case my wife stumbles upon this blog I think a handy is
in order by someone other than yours truly.
26 comments:
happy teejmas!
Buckles informs me that this month's Specialty Cocktail featured at the palm will be an Apple Blossom. You like apples blossoms?
that got some applejack in it?
My money is on Kessler getting the win for the USWNT
i'm no lawyer, but us soccer doesn't really seem to have a strong position here
men DO need to eat more food, but aside from that, i don't think the guys have a (third) leg to stand on.
Ron Darling in the WSJ today---wow:
http://www.wsj.com/articles/how-drugs-and-alcohol-fueled-the-1986-mets-1459795793?mod=e2tw
More interesting reading for the Gheorghies. This time, from The Atlantic:
"We wouldn't dream of walking into Whole Foods and stealing. But that part of people's ethical behavior turns off when they go online and they find free porn. Watching free porn is the equivalent of walking into the grocery store and walking out with food that you're not paying for."
http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/04/pornography-industry-economics-tarrant/476580/
Moley moley moley moley
i had no idea shlara had such a dirty mind
Nothing?
That was unreal. The game was great before the final two shots. Those shots might make it the best NCAA Tournament Championship game ever. Wow. Wow. Wow.
So I should've watched the game instead of catching up on the OJ series?
Hi g's...from augusta
If I fell asleep at halftime, I didn't miss anything, did I?
pretty glad i stayed awake for the whole thing. that was incredible. at halftime, i was convinced that carolina had too much for nova.
I heart Ryan Arcidiacono
Did you know this existed? How did I not know this existed??
http://tinyurl.com/zbjm4or
I hate Comcast with the heat of 1,000 suns
Because they won't carry the YES network? They're still much better than Time Warner.
The game really was amazing! And while my bracket was a mess, I had this final game and Villanova winning. Lucky I guess. It was something! Hope y'all are enjoying the return of Winter...wth?!
Dr. Rice met a GTB'r today.
Jerry, Glenn, or Donna?
uconn's ladies are giving cuse no quarter
Was she like "Hope Solo's legs though!"?
Sup gheorghies.
Post a Comment