Wednesday, May 02, 2018

Toxicology

You can find lists all over the world wide interweb ranking cover songs that superseded their original counterparts.  For all of the cruddy renditions of great songs that exist, with more added to the junkpile every year, the ones that rise above please me greatly.  There was an ORF Rock show about this a couple of years ago.

As Jules would say, "Example."

"Superman," R.E.M.
"Hurt," Johnny Cash
"Tainted Love," Soft Cell
"The Man Who Sold the World," Nirvana
"All Along the Watchtower," Jimi Hendrix
"Hallelujah," Jeff Buckley
"Do You Really Want to Hurt Me," Violent Femmes
"Sea of Love," Cat Power
"Trapped," Bruce Springsteen
"Renegades of Funk," Rage Against the Machine
"I Love Rock & Roll," Joan Jett and the Blackhearts

So I never really knew or cared about Britney Spears' song "Toxic." I can't believe I'm embedding a Britney song at G:TB, but it provides context.


Then I heard a cover of it some years back by Americana group Nickel Creek.  (No, not Nickelback.) Dug it major. Here's a more recent version.


And now, an instrumental surf version by a Canadian all-girl group in gold lamé?

Yes, please.

I can't turn it off.


These ladies are leaving Toronto and hitting the US this summer.  Look for them in NYC, Asbury Park, and Dunellen, NJ in August.

51 comments:

zman said...

Is that Busy Philipps in the middle? I dig her attitude.

TR said...

JD and the Staight Shot does an amazing version of, hm, nothing.

Squeaky said...

Instantly brought back memories of a few covers I liked back in the day.

Charlie Hunter Trio "Come As You Are" https://youtu.be/H4iAMx-nS6Y Jazz take on the song. Video shows CH playing his 8 string guitar where he plays the guitar and bass parts.

Mynabirds "The House that Heaven Built" https://youtu.be/kvpPwno7lUM Stark compared to the loudness of the Japandroids. Sounds better on vinyl than on this rip from youtube.

This cover then promptly lead me into a Japandroids listening black hole this morning.



Whitney said...

Z, the blonde? Love her. Her thigh is winsome.

Whitney said...

Squeaker, you know the Mynabirds, but do you know the 60's group the Mynah Birds?
A six-pack to whomever can name the two unlikeliest bandmates that were in the Mynah Birds...





You guys will all peek, so the answer is Neil Young and Rick James. If Rick James hadn't been arrested for being AWOL from the Navy reserves, the Mynah Birds could've ascended beyond their one single and been a very interesting band. Or not.

rootsminer said...

Come on Whit, don't give the answer to your own trivia questions! I didn't need to peek to answer that one, as I'm sure many other music snobs here didn't either.

Whitney said...

Sorry, Rootsy. I should have believed in you. I don't believe in any of the other clowns here where these matters are concerned, but please do me a favor and don't tell them I said so.

Squeaky said...

Well, after the Whitful information on the Mynah Birds, I've learned something new today which means time for a beer.

zman said...

I'm sure I've said it here before but I'll say it again because I'm repetitive ... Sturgill Simpson does some damn fine covers. "The Promise" is my favorite and "In Bloom" is good too.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-eWJmN8D820

And when I went to get that link I found this!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zfaOf70M4xs

mayhugh said...

I believe it was first brought to my attention at this location years ago, but the Cee Lo cover of Band of Horses' No One's Gonna Love You is better than the original.

Squeaky said...

Charles Bradley for the win! RIP.

Whitney said...

Listening to the Cee Lo BoH cover. Just listened to Sturgill's "The Promise." Had not heard either.

Thanks for the recs, dudes. Keep 'em coming.

zman said...

The Black Keys covered Jerry Butler and it's good.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UjmwUkwZan8

Dave said...

dunellen! love that town.

by the way, i know it's a long shot, but TR and zman are possibles . . . we are having a quatro de mayo happy hour and all gheorghies are welcome. as always, i am steeping some spicy tequila for the event.

did not know superman is a cover. one of my favorite songs . . .

rob said...

in phoenix for the first time. it’s 72 degrees and beautiful. i don’t get the sense that’s the normal way of things here.

Dave said...

my cousin said that they give you ice bags with your groceries in phoenix, so they don't cook in the car on the way home. 72 might be a record low . . .

TR said...

It’s cuatro de Mayo, and that’s the most Dave idea ever. Unfortunately my wife is inculcating my 8 y/o into the cult of Catholicism, and we have church crap and a big family party on Cinco de Mayo/Dios.

T.J. said...

¡Dios mío!

zman said...

Quattro de Mayo is the one day only 0.0% financing event at Audi.

rootsminer said...

Vaya con dios, bruh.

Whitney said...

I just heard the Wallows on Alt Nation. TR!

I have decided I think this sounds like Peter Bjorn and John.

Marls said...

Bjorn again?

mr kq said...

Cake's cover of War Pigs by Sabbath. Get some.

mr kq said...

Treepeople - Big Mouth Strikes Again

rob said...

i’m a sucker for dum dum girls’ cover of ‘there is a light that never goes out’

TR said...

I think I posted a link before on this fine blog, but David Byrne covering Whitney Houston’s I Wanna Dance With Somebody is fantastic.

https://youtu.be/izx8J6U7xzo

Squeaky said...

Burning Down the House cover Tom Jones and Nina Presson (Cardigans) https://youtu.be/iYuldgIOelY

This was from an album of covers by Tom Jones called "Reload". At one point I owned it on cd. It had few good tunes but some covers were awful at best. It was like a train wreck you could not look away.

rootsminer said...

In my opinion, Otis doing Satisfaction and Camper Van Beethoven's Interstellar Overdrive are two examples of the cover version eclipsing the original.

T.J. said...

I'm a huge CCR guy, but Ike and Tina's "Proud Mary" is better than the original.

rootsminer said...

I'll second that Teedge. It's better by a lot, and I love Creedence too.

Whitney said...

Devo’s Satisfaction is far less soulful but fun. Same with their take on Working in the Coalmine. Which I played for Dave 1000 times in college.

Marls said...

Save Ferris - Come on Eileen

Billy Joel & Robert Plant covering Love Removal Machine.

zman said...

Death Letter Blues by the White Stripes. I saw them perform it live on MTV and that's when I realized they were legit, not a gimmick. I immediately went out and got De Stijl.

zman said...

Trump's lawyers are so bad (how bad are they?), they don't know the difference between "roll" and "role." Sad! Needs a new ghosttweeter.

T.J. said...

Ichiro hanging up the cleats

rob said...

but we’re not hanging up the ichiro

rootsminer said...

Cmon Z! Jack White would not even take his guitar out of the case if San House was on the scene! I will admit that Mr. House had lost some of his vitality when he recorded in the 60s. His 1930s recordings however, are tops!

zman said...

Cmon rootsy! Clearly Son House > Jack White (Prof. Simon would retroactively fail me if I thought otherwise) but the White Stripes's cover of Death Letter Blues is damn fine. I was impressed that they even knew enough to cover Son House. Since then I understand that they're legit musicians.

Danimal said...

Billy Idol owns two of my fave covers...Simple Minds’ Don’t Yiou Forget About Me and The Doors’ LA Woman.

Danimal said...

Johnny Cash doing Nine Inch Nails’ Hurt is pretty good too, though depressing.

Dave said...

townes van zandt doing "dead flowers" is a great one. on the big lebowski soundtrack.

although i'm pretty liberal with this award, i gave zman comment of the year on sentence of dave today . . .

Squeaky said...

Ring of Fire, the Social D version, might have been played 10,000 times at Unit M.

TR said...

Thank you Celts for making this a game. I need something to do while I drink scotch.

TR said...

McHale and the other stiff doing the game are oblivious, but this big Celts comeback has come when Brad Stevens went with a huge lineup: Thornton and Monroe together, w/ Brown at the 3. Monroe was very physical w/ Embiid.

Whitney said...

Danimal’s powers of observation lacking. Read original post.

Whitney said...

And I hung up the Ichiro last summer. Sucks.

TR said...

Seriously, Danimal. Get it together.

TR said...

3 mins left in game. Ben Simmons has 1 pt, 4 assists and 5 rebounds. Maybe we can all tap the brakes before we anoint him as Magic 2.0.

rob said...

wait. whitney hung up the ichiro? do we need to have a ceremony? or an intervention?

candidly, this is not the intervention i thought i would have to have with him.

Whitney said...

Do tell

Danimal said...

oh. sorry.