It’s undoubtedly well reported and sourced, and it’s already caused ripples within Republican circles. House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy said that sections in which he was reported to call on the President to resign after Jan. 6 and was critical of Trump were false. After which audio was leaked of him saying exactly that. Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell reportedly told advisors post-Jan. 6 that “the Democrats are going to take care of the son of a bitch for us,” referring to Trump’s second impeachment trial, and “if this isn’t impeachable, I don’t know what is.” After which McConnell and most of his Republican colleagues voted not to impeach.
Look, I’m guessing that Martin and Burns didn’t get information in real time. It likely took months to gather documentation and to verify from sources. But they certainly knew about it long before the book’s pub date. And I’d argue that they should have reported what they could ASAP. It’s not only their job, but their duty – to citizens and to the republic at large.
This wasn’t some insider policy debate that the principals are trying to massage, or an innocent what-I-saw-at-the-White House travelogue. This was a president trying to subvert a free and fair election and to remain in power, enabled by one of the nation’s two major political parties. You report that when you know it, not when you have 400 pages of material. Hell, the book subtitle spells out its importance: Trump, Biden and the Battle for America’s Future.
Burns and Martin have plenty of company. ABC national correspondent Jonathan Karl’s “Betrayal” came out late last year. In it, he quoted Attorney General Bill Barr that Trump’s repeated claims of election fraud were “bullshit.” Washington Post reporters Carol Leonnig and Philip Rucker co-wrote two books, “A Very Stable Genius” and “I Alone Can Fix It,” the latter about Trump’s final year in office after he sat down with them for an interview at Mar-a-Lago.
And then there’s Bob Woodward, the Post editor and investigative Hall of Famer who’s written three books about Trump, two himself and the most recent, “Peril,” with fellow Post reporter Robert Costa about the 2020 election, Jan. 6 and the Biden inauguration. I’ve banged on Woodward in this space, when
his book “Rage” came out in the fall of 2020. Trump admitted that he knew COVID was far more serious than he let on during the winter and early spring of 2020, but downplayed the severity because he didn’t want it to hurt him politically or tank financial markets. Once COVID death tolls began to spike, Woodward could have reported what he knew and perhaps affected pandemic response decisions and potentially saved lives. Instead, he sat on the information until the book came out.
his book “Rage” came out in the fall of 2020. Trump admitted that he knew COVID was far more serious than he let on during the winter and early spring of 2020, but downplayed the severity because he didn’t want it to hurt him politically or tank financial markets. Once COVID death tolls began to spike, Woodward could have reported what he knew and perhaps affected pandemic response decisions and potentially saved lives. Instead, he sat on the information until the book came out.
It isn’t as if Trump lies, dysfunction and competence are revelations. There was plenty of daily reporting in the past five years. I’m under no illusion that any of it will change minds. Most of us have reached conclusions about Trump and the present state of our politics. But anything that further opens the curtain to the words and actions of our leaders is not only valuable but necessary.
The nation’s framers thought enough of a free press to preserve it in the First Amendment to the Constitution. The press should hold up its end of the bargain, and not just to make a buck from a book.
I agree with all of this, and OBX Dave said it ten times more succinctly than I could have.
ReplyDeleteI think Zman could have made the same case in 2-3x as many words.
ReplyDeleteI think we're beyond the point where books or journalism will persuade anyone. If only there were a way to relay the key information in a forum that doesn't require reading.
Word, OBXD. Word. If only there were some recourse.
ReplyDeletePreach, OBX dave
ReplyDeleteGood stuff, Dave.
ReplyDeleteI guess we shouldn’t be surprised that when newspaper owners are more focused on investor return than quality journalism, that journalists start acting in a similar way.
Excellent point, Marls.
ReplyDeleteGood thing that here at G:TB we're all about bringing content to the masses in a timely manner!!
ReplyDeleteExcept Day 12 of Gheorghemas. We like to hold that one back for strategery.
Saving the content enjoyed here for a book may not be the best idea.
ReplyDeleteBlasphéme!
ReplyDeletejust got back from cheerleading worlds. bittersweet. more sweet than bitter. lots of cheer, decent bit of disneying (epcot during flower and garden or food and wine festivals is very much worth doing - proper boozefest), more than a little emotion for us and our youngest in her last major club competition. done writing checks for cheer each month. on to writing bigger checks for college.
ReplyDeleteQuite a match in Manchester.
ReplyDeleteIsn’t there a Zman and Marls post waiting to go?
ReplyDeleteAlmost.
ReplyDeleteIt's waiting for sure. We work slowly.
ReplyDeleteheaded to Columbus tomorrow for a work conference, anyone got any recommendations for the birthplace of Guy Fieri?
ReplyDeletetext brother buck and brother goodstein. or text buck goodstein, jewish cowboy.
ReplyDeleteI've been to Columbus!
ReplyDeletehttps://gheorghe77.blogspot.com/2012/04/ohio-players.html
Hey, Teej, the best thing I did in Columbus was watching a super great Ohio State vs Penn State football game amid 104,000 fans. I recommend it highly.
ReplyDeleteodd doings here last night. my wife and i were driving to watch my daughter's cheer team (a different one than the one that competed last weekend) have a sendoff for the very final competition of her club career. we got a call from a very distraught kid. turns out she'd been involved in a vehicle 'incident' (will explain that terminology momentarily). she was trying to park at the cheer gym, which is in an industrial park where parking is a shitshow. she was turning left out of one lot and the sun was directly in her eyes. she didn't see an oncoming motorcyclist until it was (almost) too late. she stopped suddenly, he tried to swerve but lost control of his bike (it's a sweet harley).
ReplyDeletehe laid in the street for a bit, while first other cheer parents and then emergency responders administered aid to him. they took him away in an ambulance, but told us it was only precautionary. the bike has some scrapes on it (which we'll offer to pay to have repaired). and the sheriff's deputy on scene didn't cite my daughter because she didn't make contact (hence 'incident' and not 'accident').
my kid was mostly embarrassed once she realized the motorcyclist was okay, because the emergency vehicles blocked the road and kept traffic from entering or leaving the area all because of her.
all's well that ends well, i suppose. i could use a little less automotive drama in my life.
Glad that wasn’t worse for her. It can certainly be traumatic. My older daughter took a turn too tight and smashed up a parked car, taking the bumper off of our car in the process. That was two weeks after she got her license. I’ve never seen her cry that hard.
ReplyDeleteBut did she hit a house?
ReplyDeletehttps://gheorghe77.blogspot.com/2021/06/my-embarrassing-learning-to-drive-story.html
Or a Ferrari?
https://gheorghe77.blogspot.com/2016/08/virginia-is-for-lovers-not-drivers.html